Aldemaro Romero

Home Page

Up ]

 

Typhlichthys subterraneus

Girard, 1859

Southern cavefish

Common Name:  Southern cavefish (E), vernacular and American Fisheries Society.
Etymology:  typhlops (Gr) blind; ichthys for iktus (Gr) fish; subterraneus (L) underground.
Major synonyms:  T. osborni (Eigenmann, 1905), Typhlichthys wyandotte (Eigenmann, 1905), T. eigenmanni (Hubbs, 1938).
 
 

(Drawing by E.S. Damstra, published in Romero, 2003a).

History:  The first specimen was taken from a well near Bowling Green, Warren County, Kentucky, USA, and sent to the Smithsonian Institution by J. E. Younglove and later described by Charles F. Girard. Carl H. Eigenmann described T. osborni by differentiating from T. subterraneus based on the differences in head width and eye diameter.  Eigenmann also described a third species as T. wyandotte (the type specimen is lost). Carl Hubbs described a T. eigenmanni in 1938.  All these are synonyms of T. subterraneus a species that shows a great deal of variability, in part, due to its extensive distribution; it is possible that this "species" is actually composed of two or more actual biological species.  

 

 

Known Museum Specimens

Catalog Number Locality (all in the USA) Date Collector
AMNH 8103 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave ?

?

AMNH 18715

KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave

1903 C. H. Eigenmann 
AMNH 18176

KY: Hart Co.: Horse Cave

? C. H. Eigenmann
AMNH 22693 ? ? University of Florida
ANSP 148699 KY: Barren Co.: Mitchell's Cave 1937 G.P. Merrill
ASUMZ 9064 AR: Foulton Co.: Richardson's Cave 3 Feb 1979

Paige et al. 1981

CAS 78370 KY: Hart Co.: Horse Cave 1 Dec 1902

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91980 KY: Hart Co.: Horse Cave 2 Dec 1902 

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91981 KY: Hart Co.: Horse Cave 2 Dec 1902 

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91982 KY: Hart Co.: Horse Cave ?

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91983 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mitchell's Cave Dec 1902

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91984 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mitchell's Cave Dec 1902

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91985 KY: Edmonson Co.: Cave City 1 May 1900

C. H. Eigenmann 

CAS 91986 KY: Edmonson Co.: Cave City, Glasgow, or Mammoth Cave ? ?
CAS 91987 KY: Small cave near Mammoth Cave 1873

F.W. Putnam

CAS 91988 IN: Harrison Co.: Corydon

?

?

CAS 101310 IN: Harrison Co.: Corydon, well ?

D. S. Jordan

CAS 103928 IN: Cave near Wyandotte ? ?
CAS 125283 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave: River Styx September 1905 ?
CMNH 62046 KY: Hart Co.:    
CMNH 62325 TN: Grundy Co.:    
FMNH 3871 KY: Hart  Co.: Horse Cave 1900 Woods and Inger
FMNH 62046 KY: Hart Co.: Hidden River Cave: Horse Cave 10 November 1950 P. Smith and Huston
FMNH 62047 KY: Edmonson Co.: Floyd Collins Crystal Cave ? Woods and others
FMNH 62048  TN: Marion Co.: Crystal Cave: Near Wonder Cave, 5 mi. from Monteagle, near Route 41 23 October 1950 Woods and Inger
FMNH 62050  KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave 14 November 1950 Woods and Inger
FMNH 62051  KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave National   Park: Stillhouse Hollow Cave 15 November 1950 Woods and Inger
FMNH 62052 TN: Coffee Co.: Sink Hole Cave near Wonder Cave 26, 28 October 1950 Woods and Kanazawa
FMNH 62053  TN: Coffee Co.: Blowing Spring 29 October 1950 Kirby, Smith, Woods, Kanezawa, Harrison
FMNH 62054  TN: Coffee Co.: Blowing Spring 29 October 1950 Woods and Kanazawa
FMNH 62055 TN: Coffee Co.: Blowing Spring Cave 29 October 1950 L.P. Woods
FMNH 62056  TN: Coffee Co.: Sink Hole Cave w. of Wonder Cave or Blowing Spring 1950 ?
FMNH 62325  TN: Coffee Co.: Sink Hole Cave near Wonder Cave 26, 28 October 1950 Woods and Kanazawa
FMNH  86306 

?

? ?
INHS 50142 TN: Putnam Co.: 1965  
INHS 60575

?

?  
INHS 60576 AL: Madison Co.: 1964  
KU 3210 OK: Ottawa Co.: Peoria: Cave Spring: 2 mi. W and 1 mi. S. Peoria 24 April 1954

T. Denesha

KU 12853 KY: Edmonson Co.: 25 July 1934 ?
KU 14007 OK: Ottawa Co.: Peoria: Cave Spring: 2 mi. W and 1 mi. S. Peoria 26 November 1966

Ron S. Nolan

MCZ 780 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave September 1858

Alpheus Hyatt

MCZ 781 AL: Lawrence Co.: "Moulton" ? Peters, Thomas via L. Agassiz mid-1800's
MCZ 782

TN: Williams Co.: Lebanon

1854? J.M. Safford
MCZ 27585 MO: Jasper Co.: Wilson's Cave, Sarcoxie 1888? Hoppin, Ruth via S. Garman in 1888
MCZ 27586 MO: Jasper Co.: From a well in Sarcoxie 1888? Hoppin, Ruth via S. Garman in 1888
MCZ 27587 MO: Jasper Co.: From brook outside of Wilson's Cave near Sarcoxie; 50 feet from entrance to cave. 1888? Hoppin, Ruth via S. Garman in 1888
MCZ 35058 KY: Edmonson Co.: Mammoth Cave September 1859 Alpheus Hyatt
NLU 9659 TN: Montgomery Co.    
NLU 15000 AR: Randolph Co.:    
NLU 24998 TN: Montgomery Co.:    
NLU 28534 TN: Decatur Co.:    
NLU 28535 TN: Decatur Co.:    
NLU 28536 TN: Decatur Co.:    
NLU 28537 TN: Perry Co.:    
NLU 28538 TN: Perry Co.:    
NLU 28539 TN: Hickman Co.:    
NLU 28540 TN: Hickman Co.:    
NLU 28541 TN: Decatur Co.:    
NLU 28542 TN: Decatur Co.:    
NLU 28543 TN: Lewis Co.:    
NLU 28544 TN: Perry Co.:    
NLU 25545 TN: Perry Co.:    
NLU 28546 TN: Montgomery Co.    
NLU 28547 TN: Montgomery Co.:    
UMMZ 88027 KY: Hart Co.: Hidden River Cave at Horse Cave 28 August 1929 Creaser & Becker
UMMZ 103473 AL: Madison Co.: Shelta Cave, near Huntsville 12 May 1936 A. R. Cahn
UMMZ 103552 TN: Wilson Co.: Well at Lebanon 10 March 1937 A. R. Cahn
UMMZ 105667 TN: Hardin Co.: Cave near Dry Creek 10 February 1938 L. R. Miller and Bryan
UMMZ 133264 TN: Rutherford Co.: Well in Murfreesboro (E Castle St.) -Lee Jenkins Well ? For G. M. Edney
UMMZ 133544 TN: Rutherford Co.: Well in Murfreesboro (E Castle St.) -Lee Jenkins Well 14 April 1941 For G. M. Edney
UMMZ 133844 AR: Randolph Co.: a well ? B. C/ Marshall
UMMZ 136379 MO: Shannon Co.: Welch's Cave, on Current River 6 July 1941 C. B. Obrecht & party
UMMZ 144606 AL: Madison Co.: Cave Spring Cave, N of New Hope 1 December 1939 W. B. Jones
UMMZ 146990 AL: Madison Co.: Pond in Shelta Cave, 2 mi. N Huntsville 5 August 1939 L. Hubricht
UMMZ 150421 MO: Laclede Co.: Bennett Spring source, at Bennett State Park 4 July 1939 B. Crawford
UMMZ 156795 MO: Camden Co.: River Cave near Hahatonka; Osage River dr 18 August 1930 E. P. Creaser
UMMZ 156796 MO: Camden Co.: River Cave near Hahatonka; Osage River dr 19 August 1930 E. P. Creaser
UMMZ 157008 KY: Barren Co.: Mitchells' Cave, Glasgow ? C. H. Eigenmann
UMMZ 174850 TN: Putnam Co.: Cave 1 mi. N of Monterey-Sparta Hwy., on farm; Tennessee River dr 4 June 1953 N. Benson, Fetteroff
UMMZ 196194 TN: Montgomery Co.: Austin Peay Pit Cave, Austim Peay University Far. 17 August 1972 D. Bechler
USNM 00008563 KY: near Bowling: well ?  
USNM 00036632 KY: Hart Co.: Mammoth Cave 1884

Swain Gilbert

USNM 00036806 KY: Hart Co.: Mammoth Cave 1884 ?
USNM 00045490 KY: Mitchell's Cave 1894

E. Owsley

USNM 00089417 AL: Lauderdale Co.: Well owned by A. V. Patterson 1929

W. D. Johnston, Jr.

USNM 00091585 AL: Lauderdale Co.: Hines 1930

W. D. Johnston, Jr.

USNM 00092298 AL: Lauderdale Co.: Hines: well 1932?

W. D. Johnston Jr.

USNM 00093518 AL: Lauderdale Co.: Patterson Farm 1934

H. V. Patterson

USNM 00101172 KY: Mammoth Cave: Roaring River ?

W. P. Hay

USNM 00101501 AL: Lauderdale Co.: near Hines: Patterson Farm: well 1935

H. V. Patterson

USNM 00109468 AL: Lauderdale Co.,: near Florence: a well 1939

H. V. Patterson

USNM 00162700 MO: Shannon Co., Eminance 150 mi. E. of Springfield, Deepwell June 1952

Teacher from MO State College

USNM 00175248 AL: Madison Co.: Huntsville: 500 yds. NNE of intersection of Pulaski Pike and Oakwood Rd.: Lake in cave 15 Jun 1957

D. Blair

USNM 00199401 MO: Welch Cave: 27 mi. SW of Salem, 1 mi. N. of Akers 9 Jul 1965

Stout

USNM 00232538 TN: Putnam Co.: Blind Fish Cave; 1.8 mi. SW Calfkiller School 30 Jul 1969

R. W. Bouchard

USNM 00237003a OK: Ottawa Co.: Cave Springs 3 Oct 1971

J. H. Black

YPM AL: Madison Co.: Huntsville ? ?
ZMUC * 2 KY: Mammoth Cave 20 Dec 1879 ?
ZMUC * 3 KY: Mammoth Cave 20 Dec 1879 ?

a This is, in reality, Amblyopsis rosae (Mayden and Cross 1983).

Acronyms for museum collections:

AMNH: American Museum of Natural History

ANSP: Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia

ASUMZ: Arkansas State University Museum of Zoology (Jonesboro)

CAS: California Academy of Sciences

CMNH: Cleveland Museum of Natural History

FMNH: Field Museum of Natural History (Chicago)

INHS: Illinois Natural History Survey

KU: Kansas University

MCZ: Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard University

NLU: Northeast Louisiana University

UMMZ: University of Michigan Museum of Zoology

USNM: United States National Museum (Washington, DC)

YPM: Yale Peabody Museum, Yale University.

ZMUC: Zoological Museum of the University of Copenhagen

 

Picture courtesy of Danté Fenolio

Other Pictures:

http://www.fishbase.org/Photos/Pictures.cfm?picname=Tysub_u0.jpg

http://www.luciopesce.interfree.it/zoologia/fish.html

http://www.auburn.edu/academic/science_math/cosam/museum/musefish/holdings.htm

http://www.utexas.edu/depts/tnhc/.www/biospeleology/mocavelife/TN_001.JPG

http://www.utexas.edu/depts/tnhc/.www/biospeleology/typhlich.jpg

http://members.socket.net/~joschaper/wsocafish.html

http://animaldiversity.ummz.umich.edu/site/resources/native_fish_conservancy/Typhlichthys-subterraneus-1.jpg/view.html

http://www.conservation.state.mo.us/cgi-bin/mofwis/search.cgi?record=0100026&MATCH=exact

 

Morphological Characteristics

It reaches 90 mm of standard length (SL).  Large, broad head.  Fin ray counts is as follows: dorsal soft rays (total): 7-10; anal soft rays: 7-10; lacks pelvic fins.  10-15 branched caudal rays.  The number of vertebrae is 28-29.  Caudal fin with 0-2 rows of papillae and a vertical basal row.  Anus well in front of the anal fin in adults.  It has a port-cleithrum bone.

Troglomorphic Characters

Eye Condition:  Rudimentary eyes hidden under the skin.
Pigmentation:  Body depigmented with few non-functional pigment cells.
Scales:  Minute and embedded.
Swim (gas) bladder: They posses a swimbladder (Schubert 1993, p. 130).

Plastic responses: Under exposure to white light some individuals develop epidermal melanophores (Woods and Inger 1957)

Distribution

USA: Subterranean waters in two major disjunct ranges being separated by the Mississippi River: Ozark Plateau of central and southeastern Missouri and northeastern Arkansas; and Cumberland and Interior Low plateaus of northwest Alabama, northwest Georgia, central Tennessee and Kentucky and (possibly?) southern Indiana (ca. 37o 00' N, 86o 29' W). 

Woods and Inger (1957) noted that the type specimens of Typhlichthys wyandotte had been lost and the type-locality destroyed.  However, a well- like entrance into a cave, on the property of a car dealership in Corydon, Indiana, was discovered recently and is speculated to be the type-locality of Typhlichthys wyandotte (Lewis 2002).  That does not mean that this species is found in Indiana: a year-long study of the Binkley Cave System and associated caves in the Corydon area by Lewis and Sollman (1999) found only the related cavefish Amblyopsis spelaea. A survey of about 200 caves in the same drainage basin also failed to find Typhlichthys subterraneus (Lewis 1998).Poly and Proudlove (2004) reported that they had rediscovered the holotype of T. wyandotte (CAS 91988) and some of the syntypes of of T. orboni (CAS 78370, 91980, 91981, 91982) in the California Academy of Sciences collection.

A citation for Oklahoma is incorrect: it was based on a single, poorly preserved, 19.2-mm SL specimen from Cave Spring, Ottawa County.  Mayden and Cross (1983) reidentified the original specimen, and one specimen collected later from the same locality, as Amblyopsis rosae, the Ozark cavefish. Their identification was based on six characters utilized to distinguish Typhlichthys from Amblyopsis.

 

Habitat and Ecology

They are found in rather deep water tables, beyond 200 m in depth.

Mostly lentic but also in pools of streams at or near water table.  Found in caves which are near the water table and are therefore more uniform than other amblyopsid caves. (Noltie & Wicks 2001).  They seem to be attracted to point sources of water efflux (Schubert and Noltie 1995).  Microhabitat selection by captives was studied by D. Noltie and A. Schubert in Missouri in the early 1990s (Figg 1993).  They show

The results indicate a strong preference for large substrate sizes (Schubert 1993).

 

The population of  in Wayne County, Missouri, has been estimated to be at least 90 individuals (Pflieger 1997).  Most populations include fewer than 150 individuals.

An individual of T. subterraneus was reported in Key Cave, Alabama, the only known cave inhabited by another species of amblyopsid, Speoplatyrhinus poulsoni (Kuhajda and Mayden, 2001).

 

Detailed Distribution

State County Locality, Number of Specimens, Date Source
Alabama Dekalb Sells Cave Boschung 1961
    Browder Cave Cooper and Iles 1971
  Jackson Salt River Cave Woods and Inger 1975
  Lauderdale Hines  
    Florence  
  Lawrence Moulton Putnam 1872
  Madison Shelta Cave near Huntsville  
    Cave Spring Cave near New Hope  
Arkansas Randolph A well, one specimen, 1940 Woods and Inger 1975
  Fulton Richardson's Cave, 20 specimens, 1979 Paige et al. 1981
    Unnamed well Graening and Brown, 2000
  Stone Alexander Cave, 20, 1975 Robison and Buchanan 1988
    Cave River Cave Graening and Brown, 2000
    Clark Spring, reportedly connected to the large stream in Alexander Cave, 20, 1979  
Georgia Dade Twin Snakes Cave Cooper and Iles 1971
Indiana Harrison Corydon  
Kentucky Barren Cave City Cox 1905
    Mitchell's Cave near Glasgow  
  Edmonson Mammoth Cave  
    Stillhouse Hollow Cave  
  Hart Horse Cave  
  Pulaski Sloan Valley Cave Cooper and Baiter 1972, Dolloff et al. 2001
  Trigg   Rice et al. 1983
  Warren Bowling Green Girard 1859
    Rich Pond Orr 1934
    Mill Cave  
Missouri Cambden River Cave  
  Carter   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Dallas   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Dent   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Green Springfield  
  Howell   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  LaClede Bennett Spring  
  Oregon Roaring Spring  
  Ozark   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Phelps   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Pulaski   Dolloff et al. 2001
  Ripley   Noltie & Wicks 2001
  Shannon Welch's Cave  
  Wayne Grand Gulf Noltie & Wicks 2001
Tennessee Coffee Bowling Spring Cave  
    Crystal Cave near Monteagle  
    Sink Hole Cave near Wonder Cave  
  Decatur Baugus cave Bechler 1974
    Stewman Creek Cave Bechler 1974
  Dickson    
  Grundy Big mouth-Big room cave system, Payne's Cove Woods and Inger 1975
  Hardin Cave near Dry Creek  
  Hickman Cave Branch Cave near Pleasantville Bechler 1974, Woods and Inger 1975
  Lewis Blowing Spring Cave Bechler 1974
  Montgomery Dunbar Cave near Clarksville Woods and Inger 1975
  Overton City Water Supply Cave No. 2 at Livingston Woods and Inger 1975
  Perry Blowing Caves near Pleasantville Bechler 1974, Woods and Inger 1975
    Unnamed cave Bechler 1974
  Putnam Blindfish Cave in Long Valley Woods and Inger 1975
  Rutherford Murfreesboro  
  Smith    
  Warren Panter's Cave near Irving College Woods and Inger 1975
  Wayne Hound Dog Drop Cave Garland 2002
  Wilson Lebanon  

 

Range map of the distribution of known cavefish (Amblyopsis rosae and Typhlichthys

subterraneus) habitats in Arkansas by location and by county (From Graening and Brown, 2000).

 

Food and Feeding

Feeds mostly on copepods (60-80 of its diet), amphipods, isopods, decapods, cladocerans, non-annelid worms and aquatic insects (Poulson 1961).  Schubert (1993) found that the daily mean consumption rate is 2.68 " amphipods/day or 11.8 mg amphipod/g fish/day.

 

Physiology

This species has about 28,600 lamellae on gill filaments, their gill area is 169.1 mm2 and its metabolic rate is 0.016 O2 ml g-1 h-1.  Their branchial volume is 50 mm3, ventilation frequency is 19 (15-21), and amplitude 0.8 (0.4-1.0).  All these values as well as their thyroid activity fall into the median for other species of amblyopsids (Poulson 2001).

Reproduction and Development

Branchial (i.e., gill chamber) brooding is possible because of the position of the jugular vent and the size and shape of the gill chamber (Poulson 1963) but this has yet to be proven.  As many as 50% of the adult female population may breed in any one year.  Breeding probably occurs in late spring (April and May) in association with rising water levels (Robison and Buchanan 1988).  It is long-lived and slow growing.  They develop the first scales at three months of age and the first annulus at 7-10 months.  They become reproductively active at 22-24 months of age (Poulson 1961).

 

Fecundity is very low, perhaps fewer that 50 ova per female.  It takes about two months for free swimming young to develop from the zygote stage.  Females display parental care.  They may live for decades rather than years (Noltie and Wicks, 2001).  They have low reproductive capacity. A study of reproductive ecology and microhabitat selection was initiated in Missouri in 1991 (Figg 1991).

 

Nervous System

They show enlarged olfactory and acoustico-lateralis in their brain as well as reduced optic centers.

They have numerous neuromasts with round bulnbous cupulae, laying in a row and alternating left and tight of center.

Other Behaviors

It tends to rest motionless on the bottom for long periods of time.  It does not respond to light (Green and Romero 1997).  It shows a wide range of agosnistic behaviors (Bechler 1983) and weak rheotaxic responses (Noltie and Wicks 2001).

 

Phylogenetic Relationships

This species is probably artificially composed unrelated (paraphyletic) populations due to its extensive horizontal distribution in karsts (Bergstrom et al. 1995).

 

Conservation Status

Vulnerable (VU D2) (World Conservation Monitoring Centre, WCMC). Alabama: Protected; Arkansas: Inventory element; Missouri: Watch; Oklahoma: Extirpated; Alabama: Threatened; Georgia: rare; Indiana: Endangered; Kentucky: Special concern; Tennessee: Deemed in need of management (Noltie and Wicks 2001).

Global Rank: G4 apparently secure.  The global rank of G4 is usually assigned to species that have been recorded from more than 100 localities.  Although this species is known from sufficient localities to merit the rank of G4, its position in cave ecosystems as a predator suggests a lower (G3) rank.

Missouri State Rank: S2/S3 imperiled/vulnerable; The state rank of S2 is typically assigned to species that have been recorded from between 6-20 localities. The state rank of S3 is assigned to species that have been recorded from between 21-100 localities.

 

Threats

Water pollution in recharge areas due to urbanization and suburban housing, municipal sewage treatment plants, mining, confined animal operations, and transportation routes may threaten water quality (Aley and Aley 1997).

Sedimentation is another serious threat because the habitat requirements of this species (see above).